And now for your fleeting moment of outrage
For a few days, let's pretend that what Ben-Gvir did was somehow unique
I was somewhere between bitter and bemused at the shock-shock-I-say that met the video of fascist Israeli minister Itamar Ben-Gvir abusing captured flotilla activists on camera. For some reason this incident elicited widespread condemnation, including from the rabbinate (!) and Netanyahu himself ( 🙄). It must be said that this kind of thing goes on all day every day in Israeli prisons, where the occupying forces have unlimited power and seemingly no capacity for compassion.
An incident has to be particularly egregious and uniquely public to even garner attention, and still there seems to be no rhyme or reason why one incident will elicit outrage from across the political system while another is met with a shrug of the shoulders or, more likely, the unleashing of the full hasbaric artillery of performative outrage, as Nicholas Kristof discovered when he published something that is really quite widely known (see B’Tselem’s accurately named report, Living Hell).
The only reason anybody cares about this at all is because it was Ben-Gvir, and that probably has as much to do with internal Israeli coalition politics as it does with what he did here, which might I remind you, happens LITERALLY ALL THE TIME throughout the military prison system. Even having an incident being on camera isn’t dispositive: video of Israeli soldiers raping a Palestinian man with a knife led to the reprobates being feted as national heroes. Israel is a very sick society.
It’s all performative because of course Ben-Gvir will not face any consequences. Netanyahu needs him for the coalition, and he has a big following. But the idea that this incident, or even Ben-Gvir himself, is some kind of anomaly leaves me bitterly bemused. In fact, Ben-Gvir is the unrestrained id of Israeli -- the walking talking personification what the country has become.


To the extent that all Israeli Hasbara is coordinated, this outrage was an extremely effective move. A handful of Israeli Jews spoke out against the abuse of flotilla participants because they anticipated, correctly, the foreign nationals would have more credibility and their mistreatment would bring greater sympathy and condemnation than two and a half years of mass murder and decades of prison torture.
Agreement that restraint was called for in this situation, but not in all others, dramatically reinforces the Pyramid of Jewish Israeli Supremacy and shows it is international consensus.
Pyramid of Jewish Israeli Supremacy:
1. Israeli Euro-descended Jew >
2. Israeli SWANA-descended Jew >
3. US Diaspora Jew (two and three alternate) >
4. European Diaspora Jew >
5. Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Euro-descended South American Diaspora Jews >
6. Israeli non-Jews (a key talking point, but major problem)
7. SWANA Diaspora Jews >
8. All other Diaspora Jews (only recognized as legitimate Jews when labor or public relations needs call for it) >
9. US non-Jews >
10. European non-Jews >
11. Southeast Asian non-Jews >
12. All other non-Arab non-Jews >
13. Arab non-Jews >
14. Palestinian non-Jews (though never designated as such)